Did You Know? Italy
Imagine looking to the Church for spiritual guidance and discovering that there is more than one pope—and each claims to be the legitimate leader of Christianity. That was the extraordinary situation that confronted medieval Europe beginning in 1378.
Known as the Western Schism or the Great Papal Schism, this crisis divided the Catholic Church for nearly four decades and exposed just how deeply politics had become entangled with religion.
The Election That Divided the Church
When Pope Gregory XI returned to Rome in 1377, he hoped to restore the papacy’s traditional connection with the city. Unfortunately, Gregory died in March of 1378.
The people of Rome feared that another French pope might move the papal court back to Avignon. Under intense pressure, the cardinals elected an Italian, Bartolomeo Prignano, who became Pope Urban VI. At first, the election appeared to settle the question.
Then relations between Urban and the cardinals deteriorated. Several cardinals challenged the circumstances of his election, arguing that pressure from the Roman population had compromised their freedom to choose.
They eventually declared the election invalid and elected a rival pope, Robert of Geneva, who took the name Clement VII. Clement established his court at Avignon. Urban VI refused to step down and remained in Rome. You can see this caused a massive problem as the Catholic Church now had two rival popes.
Two Courts, Two Loyalties
Urban VI remained in Rome, while Clement VII established himself at Avignon.
European rulers chose sides according to a mixture of political interests, diplomatic relationships, and religious considerations. France supported the Avignon claimant, while England supported Urban’s Roman line. Other kingdoms and territories made their own choices, splitting loyalties across Europe.
The division affected more than the papal court. Clergy, religious communities, universities, and ordinary believers faced difficult questions about which pope they should recognize. Appointments and Church decisions could be disputed depending on which claimant someone considered legitimate. This left followers of the church in a deep state of Anxiety. People feared that marriages were not legal, sacraments were invalid, and souls were not truly absolved. Imagine receiving an official religious ruling only to discover that another papal court rejected it.
This was not simply a dispute over titles. It affected the administration and credibility of the Church. For decades various solutions were proposed, but nothing worked.
Then There Were Three
Frustrations mounted and in 1409, cardinals from both sides met at the Council of Pisa, hoping to resolve the crisis. The council decided they are going to declare both existing popes deposed and elected a new one, Petros Philargos who took the name Alexander V. They obviously forgot how they got into this mess in the first place. Not to anyone’s surprise neither of the Popes accepted the decision. The council did not solve the problem they just added to it by installing a third pope.
For a time, Europe faced three rival claimants, each asserting authority over the Church. It was a remarkable demonstration of how difficult it had become to resolve the crisis through the Church’s existing institutions.
How Was the Schism Finally Ended?
The breakthrough came with the Council of Constance, convened by the Holy Roman Emperor Sigismund, which met between 1414 and 1418. The council used the doctrine of conciliar theory stating that a general council of the Church holds higher authority than the pope. Through negotiations, political pressure, and complicated ecclesiastical proceedings, the council helped bring the rival papal claims to an end.
In 1417, the council elected Oddone Colonna, who tool the name Martin V, and was widely recognized as the legitimate pope. The Western Schism was effectively resolved and unified under Rome, although some resistance continued afterward.
The crisis had lasted almost 40 years. During this time eight different men from three different lines claimed the title of Pope. The Roman line included Urban VI, Boniface IX, Innocent VII, and Gregory XII. The Avignon Line included Clement VII and Benedict XIII. The Pisan line, which was created in a failed attempt by the Coucil of Pisa to end the schism, included Alexander V and John XXIII.
The Catholic Church has officially classified the popes from the Avignon and Pisan lines as antipopes, rival claimants to the papal throne, excluding them from official papal lineage.
Why It Matters to Italian History
The Western Schism weakened the papacy’s prestige and intensified debate about how the Church should be governed.
It also demonstrated that the pope’s authority was inseparable from European politics. Kings and princes were not passive observers; their support could determine which claimant had influence in a particular territory.
For Italy, the crisis was particularly significant because Rome was once again at the center of a struggle over the papacy’s legitimacy. The Church survived the schism, but the episode left a lasting lesson: even one of medieval Europe’s most powerful institutions could be shaken by internal division.
Related Articles:
- The Avignon Papacy: When the Popes Left Rome
- Canossa: The Emperor Who Came to Beg
- Electing a New Pope
Join us every day as we explore a fascinating fact, untold story, or remarkable piece of Italy’s history and culture. Whether your family came from Italy, you’ve traveled there, or you dream of visiting one day, this year-long journey is your daily passport to the heart of Italy. You can follow us on Facebook, Instagram or X (formerly Twitter). You can subscribe for free by filling out the form below to get it sent to your email.




